Free Counsel: A Right, Not a Charity
“In an adversary system of criminal justice, there is no right more essential than the right to the assistance of counsel.”
The proposal of this paper is quite simple: all those charged with a crime, regardless of economic status, should be entitled to free counsel. The presence of counsel is fundamental to the operation of our courts and to the assertion of the defendants’ rights. However, current eligibility criteria are so arbitrary and unworkable that determination of the availability of free counsel is either pro forma or, when meaningfully pursued, too costly. Further, the availability of this most important of rights is decided without a skilled advocate arguing for that right. For these and other reasons, eligibility determinations are not worth the time, the cost, and the threat to constitutional rights they pose.
Universal eligibility for free counsel would not only solve the problems of definition, delay, the constitutional questions raised by determination procedures, the lack of participation by counsel in the determination procedure, and perhaps most importantly, cost. It also would simplify court procedures assure counsel’s availability far earlier in the process, and, if the defendants are convicted, allow whatever funds they may have to be applied to restitution, fines, or other public purposes.
Crafting a Public Defense Career: An Interview with Assistant Federal Defender Amanda David
Molly Lauterback This is the fourth in a series of interviews with attorneys who are pursuing social change through their work. This conversation took place between Molly Lauterback, an editor and board member of the N.Y.U. Review of Law &
Discovering Family Defense: A History of the Family Defense Clinic at New York University School of Law
On its 25th anniversary, teachers of the NYU School of Law Family Defense Clinic look back at the development of an innovative practice model that helped shape the burgeoning family defense movement. As the first law school clinic of its
Bolder Management for Public Defense: Leadership in Three Dimensions
Looks at public defense leadership in three dimensions from very specific and local to broad and global.
Beyond Lawyering: How Holistic Representation Makes for Good Policy, Better Lawyers, and More Satisfied Clients
Zealous advocacy is not enough to combat the effects after a criminal sentence is served, and a holistic approach is necessary