Response to a Public Laboratory Dewey Barely Imagined: The Emerging Model of School Governance and Legal Reform
Introduction
In A Public Laboratory Dewey Barely Imagined. The Emerging Model of School Governance and Legal Reform, Liebman and Sabel argue that the current wave of education reform, which combines a centralization of standards with a devolution of authority to the local level, “can be seen as a legitimate legatee of the movement for desegregation of the schools.”
The authors hold up the Kentucky Education Reform Act of 1990 (KERA) (along with similar reform efforts in Texas) as an example of the successful implementation of this new wave of education reform. They claim that “educational reform succeeded in Texas and Kentucky because of explicit alliances that ignored traditional ideological and institutional divisions in favor of an incremental, but cumulatively transformative, exploration of solutions lying between top-down standards and bottom-up school-based reforms.”
While KERA indeed exemplifies the new wave of education reform described by Liebman and Sabel, I believe we must be cautious in interpreting the Kentucky reform experience as a success. In my own research on KERA, I have found that, despite the fanfare surrounding the state’s ambitious effort, the reform has been largely unsuccessful in raising student achievement and in narrowing the gap in student achievement across rich and poor districts. There is some evidence, however, that the reform has had modest positive effects on the test scores of black students. This suggests that perhaps the current wave of education reform, as exemplified by KERA, does show promise for addressing some of the pervasive disparities that motivated the original movement for school desegregation, as Liebman and Sabel propose.
Suggested Reading
#SayHerName: Racial Profiling and Police Violence Against Black Women
Andrea J. Ritchie{{Andrea J. Ritchie is a civil rights attorney who has led groundbreaking research, litigation, and advocacy efforts to challenge profiling, policing, and physical and sexual violence by law enforcement against women, girls and LGBTQ people of color for
My Twenty-Twos: Mentoring the Young Men Emerging Community
The kid’s name was Lil’ Yo—well, that’s what all his little buddies called him—and immediately his presence snagged my attention.
Labor Law and the NLRB: Friend or Foe to Labor and Non-Union Workers?
Wilma B. Liebman{{Former Member and Chairman, National Labor Relations Board, 1997-2011; visiting distinguished scholar Rutgers University School of Management and Labor Relations 2015-17; adjunct faculty, NYU Law School, spring 2015 and 2016. This article is based on remarks at the
Don't Let Trump-- or Biden-- Distract from the Real Victims of the Espionage Act
During the First World War, the Espionage Act was overwhelmingly used for the prosecution of dissidents, the Black press, radical labor, and socialists.