Holistic Advocacy: An Important but Limited Institutional Role
Introduction
Many criminal law practitioners and academics have promoted “holistic advocacy” as a way to improve the institutional quality of indigent criminal defense services. Although holistic advocacy may greatly enhance a public defender’s practice, it has practical, professional, and ethical limitations as an institutional model. This article explores these limitations. I begin this article by presenting the holistic advocacy model and its benefits. I then examine the potential hazards of holistic advocacy as an institutional model in light of a public defender’s unique client responsibilities. Collateral consequences are examined in particular, to illustrate how holistic advocacy can offer many benefits, but also raise potential problems if overemphasized institutionally. Finally, I conclude that while holistic advocacy may help to decalcify entrenched and sometimes myopic “traditional” defense practices, the holistic advocacy model should be implemented with caution, and a traditional trial practice model should remain the institutional priority.
Suggested Reading
#SayHerName: Racial Profiling and Police Violence Against Black Women
Andrea J. Ritchie{{Andrea J. Ritchie is a civil rights attorney who has led groundbreaking research, litigation, and advocacy efforts to challenge profiling, policing, and physical and sexual violence by law enforcement against women, girls and LGBTQ people of color for
My Twenty-Twos: Mentoring the Young Men Emerging Community
The kid’s name was Lil’ Yo—well, that’s what all his little buddies called him—and immediately his presence snagged my attention.
Labor Law and the NLRB: Friend or Foe to Labor and Non-Union Workers?
Wilma B. Liebman{{Former Member and Chairman, National Labor Relations Board, 1997-2011; visiting distinguished scholar Rutgers University School of Management and Labor Relations 2015-17; adjunct faculty, NYU Law School, spring 2015 and 2016. This article is based on remarks at the
The Ongoing Nakba: Toward a Legal Framework for Palestine
If the international community takes its crimes seriously, then the discussion about the unfolding genocide in Gaza is not a matter of mere semantics.