Immigrant Workers and Workers’ Compensation after Hoffman Plastic Compounds, Inc. v. N.L.R.B.
Introduction
In August of 2000, Guillermo Medellin, an undocumented immigrant from Mexico, was injured while working at a construction site in Boston. Unable to work due to his injury, Mr. Medellin applied for workers’ compensation benefits and prevailed at his initial administrative hearing despite the opposition of his employer, Cashman KPA, and the employer’s insurer. Not once did Mr. Medellin’s immigration status arise as an obstacle to his recovering benefits at the initial hearing. The law in Massachusetts, as in most other states, was clear: undocumented immigrants were covered by workers’ compensation on the same terms as any other worker. Two years later, however, Mr. Medellin’s undocumented status was the sole basis of an appeal by his employer to the Massachusetts Department of Industrial Accidents. What changed? In March 2002, the Supreme Court held in Hoffman Plastic Compounds, Inc. v. N.L.R.B. that an undocumented worker fired in retaliation for his support of union organizing at work was ineligible for backpay under the National Labor Relations Act (“NLRA”). The Court reasoned that an award of backpay to a worker not “available” to legally work in the United States was beyond the remedial discretion of the National Labor Relations Board (“NLRB”) because it conflicted with the Federal Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (“IRCA”), which prohibits the employment of undocumented immigrants. It observed that an award of backpay to an undocumented worker “not only trivializes the immigration laws, it also encourages and condones future violations.” Notably, the undocumented worker in Hoffman had submitted false documents to obtain employment in violation of the IRCA’s employment verification provisions. The Court stated that it could not allow the Board to “award backpay to an illegal alien for years of work not performed, for wages that could not lawfully have been earned, and for a job obtained in the first instance by a criminal fraud.” Employers have taken the Hoffman decision as a green light to contend that undocumented workers are without a range of state and federal workplace rights, including the right to receive workers’ compensation benefits after suffering a job-related injury. The majority of these challenges have failed. In the workers’ compensation context, for example, state courts and agencies have overwhelmingly upheld the rights of undocumented immigrants to receive benefits after Hoffman. Nevertheless, two state courts have relied on Hoffman to allow the suspension of wage-loss benefits under workers’ compensation laws for undocumented immigrants.
Suggested Reading
#SayHerName: Racial Profiling and Police Violence Against Black Women
Andrea J. Ritchie{{Andrea J. Ritchie is a civil rights attorney who has led groundbreaking research, litigation, and advocacy efforts to challenge profiling, policing, and physical and sexual violence by law enforcement against women, girls and LGBTQ people of color for
Labor Law and the NLRB: Friend or Foe to Labor and Non-Union Workers?
Wilma B. Liebman{{Former Member and Chairman, National Labor Relations Board, 1997-2011; visiting distinguished scholar Rutgers University School of Management and Labor Relations 2015-17; adjunct faculty, NYU Law School, spring 2015 and 2016. This article is based on remarks at the
Law and the Questions and Answers of Workplace Mobilization
Michael M. Oswalt{{Michael M. Oswalt is an Assistant Professor at Northern Illinois University College of Law.}} Organizing is risky. Some workers join in and get fired, others face intimidation and drop out, while most–sensing the tension between legal rights and
Conservative Progressivism in Immigrant Habeas Court: Why Boumediene v. Bush is the Baseline Constitutional Minimum
Ever since Boumediene was decided federal judges have not applied the full force of all six of Boumediene’s holdings to immigrant habeas cases, and as a direct result immigration advocates lost their most important cases to date.